THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
HISTORICAL, SOCIOLOGICAL AND PHILOSOPHICAL
DIMENSIONS REFLECTED IN THE NOVELS OF SELECTED
AFRICAN WRITERS
A Dissertation
Presented to the
Faculty of the GraduateSchool
BatangasStateUniversity
BatangasCity
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
Doctor of Philosophy in English Language and Literature
by
NGUYEN THI MINH LOAN (SUMMER)
2015
THAING
233 trang |
Chia sẻ: huong20 | Ngày: 15/01/2022 | Lượt xem: 363 | Lượt tải: 0
Tóm tắt tài liệu Historical, sociological and philosophical dimensions reflected in the novels of selected african writers, để xem tài liệu hoàn chỉnh bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
UYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE PAGE ...............................................................................................
APPROVAL SHEET ...................................................................................
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ...............................................................................
DEDICATION .............................................................................................
TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................................... i
CHAPTER I: THE PROBLEM ............................................................................... 1
Introduction ........................................................................................ 1
Statement of the Problem .................................................................. 7
Scope, Delimitation and Limitation of the Study ................................ 8
Significance of the Study ................................................................. 10
CHAPTER II: REVIEW OF LITERATURE ......................................................... 14
Conceptual Literature ...................................................................... 14
Literature and Philosophy of Life ..................................................... 14
Significant Works of African Writers ................................................ 23
Literary Techniques ......................................................................... 30
Critical Approaches for Novel Analysis ........................................... 32
Research Literature ......................................................................... 37
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
ii
Synthesis of the Literature Reviewed ............................................. 45
Theoretical Framework ................................................................... 48
Conceptual Framework ................................................................... 54
Definition of Terms .......................................................................... 57
CHAPTER III: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ................................................ 60
Research Design ............................................................................ 60
Treatment of Materials .................................................................... 62
CHAPTER IV: ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION ...................................... 65
CHAPTER V: SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION .... 179
Findings .........................................................................................180
Conclusion .....................................................................................189
Recommendations .........................................................................190
BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................ 222
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
1
CHAPTER I
THE PROBLEM
Introduction
There is a close link between philosophy and literature. While
philosophy supplies ideology and themes for literature, literature, on the
other hand, provides vivid illustrations of the meaning and abstract
thought of philosophy. Literature is considered as a channel to show the
author’s philosophy of life. Indeed, in literature the philosophical theme
is conveyed through literary works and is an essential part of their
aesthetic value. There is a considerable number of well-known works in
the world literature in which philosophical views are put forward,
suggested, or play a central role such as Dostoyevsky’s Brothers
Karamazov, Crime and Punishment, and The Idiot; Tolstoy’s War and
Peace; Proust’s In Search of Lost Time; Mann’s MagicMountain, etc. By
studying literary works, readers are introduced central philosophical
issues relating with freedom, responsibility, religious belief, personal
identity, etc.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
2
Beside reflecting on philosophy, literature also reflects the historical
and sociological dimensions of the society. That literature is a reflection
of the society has been widely acknowledged. Literature influences the
society, and the society is reflected in literature; therefore, there has
been a close interaction between them. The readers can explore a
variety of historical and socio-political themes in many works of famous
writers such as colonialism, post-colonialism, morality, racial identity,
oppression, politics, leadership, gender issues, war, etc. According to
Diamond (1989), a literary work can provide a more detailed picture of a
society in terms of cultural, social, religious, and political dimensions
more than any history textbooks and anthropological records do. This is
exemplified in the works of many world famous writers. For example,
Wordsworth creates wonderful poems to praise humanitarian aspect of
the French revolution in the earlier phase, but later his poetry focuses on
its bloodiness and violence. Another example is Charles Dickens’ novels
whose themes consist of the consequences of industrialization like the
sufferings of the poor, hypocrisy of the privileged class, government
corruption, and many others.
Africa experienced a variety of cultural clashes and political crises
from the early colonial days when the Europeans came and conquered
this continent. Achebe, a Nigerian writer, wrote that the time and place in
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
3
which he was raised was “a strongly multiethnic, multilingual, multi-
religious, somewhat chaotic colonial situation” (Achebe, The Education
of a British-Protected Child: Essays, 2009, p.39). These words describe
Nigeria in particular and other countries in Africa in the period from the
end of the 19th century to the 21st century.
For the countries in Africa, the experience of colonialism is
considered as the one of the most important factors in understanding the
present condition of the African continent, the African people and their
history. Therefore, a close examination of the phenomenon of
colonialism is essential to assess not only the economic and political
development in Africa but also the African people’s perception of
themselves.
African literature has increasingly gained much interest in literary
research for the last three decades. Many critics have devoted much
energy to identify western influence on modern African literature.
However, the concept of influence have been subject to re-evaluation
and revision because critics often impose Western norms on analyzing
African literary works in terms of themes, techniques of writing,
philosophy, etc. While these studies have made insight interpretations of
content and meaning of the African works, less is known of the influence
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
4
of the African traditional roots on African literature and the influence of
African writers as philosophers on African people’s perception.
From the beginning of colonial situation, literature was the sharp
weapon of African writers to oppose colonialism and proudly assert the
values of the cultures that the colonials had tried to destroy. Fictional
works in many African nations has been very much influenced by the
cultural and political experiences of the country. Therefore, many of
African writers chose to use their works to explore, portray, and expose
these social experiences in their different works. As Ojaide states, “there
is, culturally speaking, no art for art’s sake in Africa. Every literary work
has a social function” (Ojaide, Modern African Literature and Cultural
Identity, 1992, p.44). Among African writers, Chinua Achebe, Ayi
Kwei Armah and Tsi-tsi Dangarembgaare the pioneers in using the pen
as the weapon against colonialism.
Chinua Achebe defines his writings as part of a “process of re-
storing peoples who had been knocked silent by the trauma of all kinds
of dispossession” (Achebe, Home and Exile, 2000, p.79). Achebe takes
up the responsibility as an Igbo writer who is to help his people regain
belief in itself and dignity that is destroyed by Western colonialism.
Ayi Kwei Armah is undoubtedly one of the most excellent writers of
the second generation of African writers which comes after Achebe. In
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
5
an autobiographical article, “One Writer's Education” (West Africa,
1985), Armah described himself as not simply a Ghanian and a West
African but “ most significantly as an African”. One of the strengths of his
writing is his use of African history and myths to emphasize the
originality and complexity of African cultures before the incursion of
colonialism into the continent. His writings are realistic descriptions of
the African continent in such a way that his novels can be seen as a
sociological report on the social and politcal situation of Africa.
Tsi-tsi Dangarembga is a fabulous African female writer. Her
writings transmit political messages regarding female oppression and
colonial domination. She earned much praise from literary critics
because of her complex depiction of racial and gender struggles in a
rural African society.
Therefore, the researcher intended to analyze the three novels by
Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga respectively: No Longer at Ease
(1960), Fragments (1971) and Nervous Conditions (1988) because an
exploration of the three chosen writers of the three different African
countries (Nigeria, Ghana and Zimbabwe) and of two sexes would
reveal a number of common concerns in terms of historical, sociological
and philosophical dimensions. The historical basis for this search is that
throughout Africa there are close similarities in both traditional cultures
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
6
and contemporary situations. The researcher attempted to make
comparisons and drawing parallels among these novels by Achebe,
Armah and Dangarembga in oder to generalize the whole Africa.
The wisdom embodied in the selected works of these African
writers could be one of the motivating factors that could help readers in
the world understand about internal and external pressures African
people suffered as well as the values they lost in colonial and post-
colonial periods. Therefore, the readers may establish their high
appreciation of African culture and history.
Besides, many scholars have already studied the various themes of
No Longer at Ease, Fragments and Nervous Conditions such as
classes, cultures, corruption, etc. However, there is not much analysis
on the historical, social and philosophical insights of these novels. Also,
these African writers’ philosophy of life gleaned from the three novels
has not received enough attention from the literary circles.
Last but not least, Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga’s life, works
and life philosophy exemplify noble values of a person and a nation,
which is worthy of attention. Therefore, as a teacher, the researcher
would like to expose her students to literature and culture outside of an
Eastern country. She wants her students to gain an appreciation of a
foreign culture while also gaining insight into their own culture, seeing
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
7
their own society through a different and objective lense. Moreover, she
wants to equip her students with a sense of values to guide and allow
them to embrace a good philosophy of life and clarify life goals.
With this objective in her mind, the researcher was deeply
motivated to explore and undertake an analysis of how historical,
sociological, philosophical perspectives reflected in the selected works
to bring out the philosophy of life of Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga.
Statement of the Problem
This study primarily aims to analyze the historical, sociological,
philosophical dimensions in the novels of selected African writers.
Specifically, the study answered the following questions:
1. What historical events are reflected in the novels of Chinua Achebe,
Armah and Dangarembga?
2. How do the novels convey the sociological character of the time as
regards:
2.1. religious practices;
2.2. social practices;
2.3. educational practices; and
2.4. political practices?
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
8
3. What literary techniques are utilized to highlight African way of life in
terms of:
3.1. Symbolism;
3.2. Flashback;
3.3. Foreshadowing;
3.4. Figures of speech?
4. What literary approaches are prevalent in the treatment of the
selected novels?
5. What philosophy of life of the writers may be gleaned from the
analyses of the novels?
Scope, Delimitation and Limitation of the Study
This study analyzed the historical, sociological and philosophical
dimensions embodied in Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga’s selected
literary pieces pointing out their philosophy of life. Likewise, this paper
tries to present the historical events, sociological character of the time,
the literary devices and literary approaches used in unveiling these
African writers’ philosophy of life.
This study employed the qualitative method of research in
analyzing the authors’ philosophy in the representative literary works
chosen. Likewise, this analysis made use of the historical, sociological
and philosophical approaches as the bases for analysis. In particular,
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
9
the historical and the sociological approaches are supported by the
theory of Postcolonialism and Cultural Relativism while Frankl’s Theory
on the Meaning of Life was used to investigate Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga’s life philosophy behind their writing. Other approaches in
literary criticism that may be employed in the analysis like the
biographical criticism and psychological criticism are not part of this
study.
This paper also involved content analysis, which is a systematic
technique in analyzing message content and message handling. The
data analysis in this research centered on data seeking and the
extraction of meaning from Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga’s
selected literary works. Much effort was focused on the task of recording
data or making notes through concepts and categories; linking and
combining abstract concepts; extracting the essence; organizing
meaning; writing an understanding; and drawing conclusions.
The essential features in the treatment of materials were
considered by the researcher in the conduct of this study. The general
rules cited by Alkiere (2014) as regards the four standards a piece of
literature particularly that of a novel should abide to in order to be
considered literary guided in the selection of works under study.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
10
The representative literary works were analyzed: No Longer at
Ease by Achebe, Fragments by Armah and Nervous Conditions by
Dangarembga. The said selections were chosen because of the
correlation between the aforementioned themes, literary devices and
approaches which helped in unveiling the authors’ philosophy of life.
Typical for African novels, No Longer at Ease, Fragments and Nervous
Conditions address the cultural and social changes in African society.
They illustrate the effects of the social, economic and political situation
on the behavior and mental conditions of the characters. Although these
novels have been the subject of much critical study and debates within
and outside the literary circles, but enough attention has not been paid
to a study of these novels to bring about Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga’s philosophy of life.
Significance of the Study
The germaneness of literary analysis as a vital part of a research
study is emphasized in terms of its implication to a number of
individuals. Therefore, it is vital to spell out how this study is beneficial to
academic managers, working professionals, college instructors of
literature, students of literature, members of the community, and other
researchers.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
11
Academic Managers. This paper will help them include
developmental priorities, programs, projects and policies in the
educational institutions to ensure that literary appreciation and critiquing
may be integrated in the academe. This will also inspire them to spawn
activities related to humanizing education through the study of literature
in the curricula that will educate the academic community about the
study of literature which is about human being: their daily lives as well as
their exceptional, towering experiences.
Working Professionals. This study will be beneficial for them in
the sense that at whatever circumstance they may find themselves their
own philosophy of life from their readings of the selected works. These
works humanize as they educate them in the art of living. At their
maturity these professionals reminisce their past and realize that their
readings have broadened and revitalized their life. It has given a deeper
meaning to their existence. Likewise, they may be inspired to highly
appreciate the folklore and culture in the past and their roles in affirming
the dignity of their people. These initiatives may help these working
people to embrace a good philosophy of life, clarify life goals, and
revitalize working relationships within their workplaces.
College Instructors of Literature. This dissertation will be helpful
in the instructor’s methodology in teaching literature as an inquiry into
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
12
using the appropriate literary theories and approaches in literary
analysis. This will lead to treating literary criticism as a worthwhile
exercise that includes, among others, the identification of a meaningful
theme and the investigation of devices and approaches to reveal such
themes. In addition, this will provide them with opportunities to touch the
concept of historical, sociological and philosophical dimensions in
selected works in their literature classes and open their students’ mind
and hearts to the philosophy of life of the author that may be drawn from
them.
Students of Literature. This study will give them an extensive and
profound outlook in life as regards the historical, sociological, and
philosophical dimensions of literature through the lives and experiences
of the characters in the selected literary pieces. It will also make them
realize that literature may be the writers channel for philosophical human
transformation. In addition, this paper will make them treat literature as a
work of art distinguished from other texts through content and form, and
eventually intensify their appreciation of novels and inspire them to
engage in literary analysis as an academic activity.
Members of the Community. This paper will make them more
mindful of their social responsibility in the community. This will make
them understand that some of the belief systems and practices at home
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
13
and the community do not often help in establishing equal and valued
roles for young students, and thus should be sidestepped.
Other Researchers. Researchers will be benefitted by this study
through the analysis and treatment of materials, and through the careful
investigation of both theme and form in literary genres. Likewise, this
paper will enlighten them on the process of drawing out literary theories
and utilizing critical approaches in literary analysis.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
14
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
This chapter presents the review of literature that is critical in the
establishment of concepts and theories that would effectively
substantiate the study.
Conceptual Literature
The review of conceptual literature yields four constructs, which
may be used in the analysis and interpretation of the works dissected.
These constructs include: literature and philosophy of life, significant
works of African writers, literary techniques and critical approaches in
novel analysis.
Literature and Philosophy of Life
It is widely acknowledged that literature reflects society and depicts
human life. According to Plato, literature imitates life, that is, it
represents the world as it is. As an imitation of human action, literature
presents a picture of what people think, say and do in the society
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
15
through characters who convey certain messages for different purposes
through their words and actions. A literary piece is based on authors’
intention and includes the attitudes, morals and values of the society
because no writer can live out of the world around him. Tomeldan, et. al.
(1986) also said that literature is a product of life and about life. It offers
an experience in which people can participate as they read and test
what they read by their own experience. By reading literature, people
can get something of value such as an understanding, a new
awareness, a feeling of pleasure, etc. In essence, life illuminates
literature as much as literature illuminates life.
Besides, writers create characters with their words, actions and
reactions to convey certain messages for the purpose of education,
information and entertainment. It is not possible to find a work of
literature without any attitudes, morals and values of the society.
Therefore, literature is one of the best media people can use to
understand their society and even themselves.
There are different forms of literature among which writers can
choose one suitable for his needs and intention such as essays, short
stories, dramas, or novels. However, in terms of representation of
different aspects of the society’s life, novels becomes increasingly
popular compared with other forms of literature.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
16
One reason is their expansion of social scope. It means that novels
most addressed the domestic and social concerns of different classes in
the society, even the middle and working classes. A good illustration is
Leo Tolstoy’s War and Peace, which consists of nearly six hundred
characters of different classes from the aristocracy to the poor.
Besides, novels engage the readers’ thought and immerse them in
the world of ideas and themes. Indeed, each novel consists of a variety
of subjects of social significance such as class, race, politics,
economics, etc. In terms of the writer’s choice of materials, the novels
may be psychological, historical or social in content. A good example is
Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin and Sinclair’s The Jungle. Other novels are
personal or psychological regarding human relationship, conflicts,
desires, and fears like Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre or William
Makepeace Thackeray’s Vanity Fair.
Another explanation for the popularity of novels is the range of the
kinds of novels- scientific fiction, adventure, detective, romantic, etc.
Hence, writers are free to choose his favourite form to express his
intentions and purposes. Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
is a good example of adventure novels.
Furthermore, a novel is long enough for writers to describe fully the
world around them and to create a large number of incidents where
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
17
characters can express their personality, a more complicated plot, a
more elaborative use of setting and a greater complexity of themes. It is
capable of revealing both a broader and deeper view of human nature
and human experience.
Last but not least, novels can reveal the spirit of the times so subtly
that they have potential for shaping the consciousness of hundreds of
generations. F.Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby and Graham
Greene’s The Quiet American are typical illustrations.
Hence, novels help readers understand social realities in different
periods of time. To do this, a writer should interpret the world and even
himself to transfer his ideas to his readers and inspire, guide and
challenge them.
Novels commonly trace the depth of an individual, a group of
people, or a world. Novelists make a work of art and offer both a
representation of and a response to reality. For example, the African
novels shared a similar theme of reaction to the negative views about
the history of Africa and Africans. The writers aim to reconstruct and
assert the true cultural identity of the African people and assure them
“that their past with all its imperfections was not one long night of
savagery from which the Europeans acting on God’s behalf delivered
them” (Achebe, The Novelist as Teacher, 1988). Besides, Said has
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
18
deeply explored the role of the novel in the colonial and imperial
enterprise of Western colonialism. He argues eloquently that “stories are
at the heart of what explorers and novelists say about strange regions of
the world, they also become the method colonized people use to assert
their own identity and the existenceof their own history” (Said, Culture
and Imperialism, 1993, p.xii). This approach appears in the works of
African writers such as Achebe, Ngugi wa Thiong’o, Elechi Amadi, Alan
Paton, and Camara Laye.
The present study follows the notion that “literature has no
autonomy outside reality” and that its analysis aims “to show the literary
work as a significant statement with a direct relevance to the African
experience” (Irele, The Criticism of Modern African Literature, 1971,
p.41). The novel’s capacity to map and reorganize reality has made it
the most convenient medium for African writers seeking to rethink their
social worlds intransitional and postcolonial times.
To sum up, novels are one of the best tools for writers to reflect any
changes of the society and the writer’s intentions. Writers like Achebe
have shown that the role and function of novels must change to suit the
cause of the user. Therefore, the notion that a novel is a reflection of
social reality is a highly acknowledged medium in the analysis of the
historical, sociological and philosophical perspectives of Achebe, Armah
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
19
and Dangarembga’s novels, No Longer at Ease, Fragments and
Nervous Conditions.
Philosophy of life may be defined as an overall vision or attitude
toward life and the purpose of life. There are some ways of
understanding philosophy of life.
The first viewpoint by Peck (in Schmidt, 2002), a contemporary
psychiatrist, explains that people need a “map” to find their way through
life. Maps do not exist naturally; therefore, if people want to have their
maps, they have to create their own maps, which requires great effort.
The more effort they spend appreciating and perceiving reality, the
larger and more accurate their maps will be. Some people stop making
it early, so their maps are small and sketchy. Only a small number of
people continue making their maps until they die; therefore, their maps
are enlarged, refined and redefined. The philosophers affirm that people
should revise their maps continually because the world always changes.
The second viewpoint is from the ancient philosopher Plato (in
Schmidt, 2002). He uses the cave to illustrate his belief that people are
trapped by their imperfect, subjective impressions of the world. People
need to use their reasoning abilities to escape from this trap and to find
a more accurate understanding of themselves and their world.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
20
In the third viewpoint, Keen and Valley-Fox (in Schmidt, 2002)
explain that people need a “myth” to explain their lives, which is similar
to Peck’s concept of a map which guides...ons” and "the metaphysics of African healing" in
“The Healers”, the dominant concern of two novel histories was to divest
the ancient godlike kings of their false glory. In Armah's postcolonial
fiction - The Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born, Fragmentsand Why Are
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
40
We So Blest?- the theme of tyranny and political corruption was linked to
the colonial middle class elite and the ancient kings. Armah achieved
this didactic creative purpose by exploiting a variety of symbols, images,
scatology and dystopian metaphors. Unlike the heroes in the two
histories, Armah's postcolonial protagonists wereso intensely paralysed
by unrelieved despair, passivity and self-alienation that they hardly
functioned as conventional heroes. Instead of the traditional hero,
Armah's protagonists like the Man, Baako, Modin and Solo operated as
anti-heroes or unimportantpeople, trapped permanently in limbo. Despite
the devitalizingenvironment around them, the postcolonial heroes were
committed to using their talents in transforming the society and
empowering the oppressed nation.
Shen (2000) examined Achebe’s Things Fall Apart, No Longer at
Ease, and Anthills of the Savannah to reaffirm African national identity
and dignity from another approach. The study adopted the Marxist
theoretical perspective in revealing the issue of social class in three of
Chinua Achebe’s novels to enable the reader to reappraise Achebe’s
novels from a class perspective. The findings of the study showed that
social class is such an important issue that it affects the main
characters’ fate. Okonkwo in Things Fall Apart and Obi Okonkwo in No
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
41
Longer at Ease are trapped in their own social classes. In Anthills of the
Savannah, Chris and Ikem seize initiatives to overcome class borders.
In terms of African slavery, Axiotou (2008) explored how Syl
Cheney Coker’s The Last Harmattan of Alusine Dunbar (1990), Ama Ata
Aidoo’s The Dilemma of a Ghost(1964), Ayi Kwei Armah’s
Fragments(1970), and Buchi Emecheta’s The Slave Girl(1979) re-think
the history of transatlantic slavery. The findings showed that the texts of
these four contemporary West African authors revealedproblems of
writing silence and narrating a history which is impossible to fully
retrieve. By attending to the violence and silencing related with the
history of slavery, as well as the difficulty of writing, and narrating,
history from the perspective of silence all the texts perform acts of
resistance against the forgetting enacted in and among their
communities, and the silencing of colonial modernity, which has turned
the history of transatlantic trade into a non-issue. The findings also
indicated that although all four authors came from different historical
situations, each provided powerful and influential examples of undoing
historical silences and absences, not by imposing voices or presences,
but by tracing the gaps in the historical representation of slavery. The
silent, but not silenced stories of the slave trade that these authors
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
42
narrate in their attempts to speak to the history of slavery bring dis/order
to the national and communal milieu.
Similarly, Bubenechik (2012) depicted the traumatic condition of the
formerly colonised indigenous peoples of Africa and Canada. The study
examined the two postcolonial trauma novels, Tomson Highway's Kiss
of the Fur Queen (1998) and Tsitsi Dangarembga's Nervous
Conditions (1988). They are first-hand record of colonial experience
under the control of the British colonists of the second half of the
twentieth century. In the study of the novels Nervous
Conditions and Kiss of the Fur Queen, the study explored the formation
of colonial and postcolonial identities, the nature and impact of colonial
trauma and the possibility of resistance on the side of the colonised. The
researcher worked towards identifying the differencesbetween
indigenous and Western concepts of trauma and identity, and study the
challenges of postcolonial literatures. Healso explored the concept of
cultural hybridity as presented in the novels and studied the impact of
trauma on identity construction. The findings of the study showed the
extent of trauma influences and shapes identity, the differences between
the antagonistic cultures as well as the development of colonial trauma,
which may shed a different light on the Western study of trauma. The
study also revealed the natives' means for dealing with the traumas
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
43
brought about by the process of colonisation and the authors' reasons
and intentions for writing these novels.
In terms of female oppression, Nash (1997) examined three novels
by African women for their insightful treatment of education, a key
development issue. These novels wereThe Joy of Motherhood by
Nigerian writer Buchi Emecheta, Zimbabwean writer Tsitsi
Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions, and Our Sister Killioy by Ama Ata
Aidoo from Ghana. The theoretical framework of the study was guided
by contemporary development perspectives, notably the concept of
empowerment within Gender and Development literature, which
emphasized the importance of seeking women’s voices and listening to
their views on issues of concern for themselves and their communities.
The findings indicated that reading women’s creative writing is one way
of hearing women’s voices. Educational themes that feature in the
discussion and analysis of the novels were the constraints that African
women face in making decisions about their daughters’ futures; the
sexism and alienation that girls encounter in their pursuit of Western
schooling; and a critique, in the context of neocolonialism, of the
educated African elite who emigrate to developed countries, constituting
a “brain drain”. The three novels made a valuable contribution to
understanding educational issues in developing countries and
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
44
suggested broad principles upon which future efforts to address people’s
needs in this area cound be based. Above all the thesis concluded that
fiction is a powerful vehicle of communication.
Similarly, Rodgers, R.J (2013) explored the representation of
women, identity and education in the works of Tsitsi Dangarembga,
Nervous Conditions (1989) and The Book of Not (2006), and Kopano
Matlwa, Coconut (2007) and Spilt Milk (2010), through the lens of
postcolonial studies. The researcher focused on how African women are
represented in the texts at particular socio-historical situations, including
implications and interpretations of the literal and cultural shift from the
indigenous, rural or segregated environments to Western, urban and
racially mixed ones. The study explored the texts in terms of symbolics
of food, language, accents, family, academic settings, and the liberating
and limiting elements associated with each. The findings showed that
the authors presented a complicated reality for the women of the novels.
The representation of women in the novels varies, leaving few
successful role models for navigating workable identities for the
characters as mothers, wives, and autonomous individuals. Besides the
novels offer interesting imaginaries for the future of their respective
countries and promote education tempered with a respect for home
cultures and racial compromise.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
45
Regarding the authors’ writing intention, Jappe (2001) aimed to
search the African identity through analyzing Achebe’s three novels
Things Fall Apart, A Man of the People and Anthills of the Savannah. He
regarded these novels as Achebe's continuous quest for the identity of
Africa. The values Achebe stressed for constructing African identity in
these novels are different, based on the need of the society at a
particular time. His view of identity is that identity can be invented and is
not fixed, and Achebe's writings do provide Africans with a channel to
explore their culture which shapes their perception of their nations and
themselves.
Synthesis of the Literature Reviewed
The foregoing literature reviewed yields basic truth that literature
can be a writer’s channel for conveying his philosophy of life and the
social character of the time, and that literature is a criticism of life as
presented at a particular time and in a particular place. Thus, in
analyzing the novels the reader shares with the author and the
characters their experiences and aspirations, which are reflected in the
thematic substance of the literary pieces.
The review of literature has provided the present study with some
constructs that helped build up the theoretical framework on the
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
46
historical, sociological, philosophical dimensions as reflected in the
selected works of Achebe. These constructs were drawn from the
theories, concepts, and ideas of literary scholars and critics. From these
insights, the researcher drew out four general concepts which, in
themselves, were constructs such as literature and philosophy of life,
significant works of African writers, literary techniques and critical
approaches in novel analysis.
The presentation and treatment of subject matter for each literary
research tend to manifest the growing concern for the development of
African literature.
The studies reviewed tend to point out that all of them are related
with the present work one way or another. Specifically, the ones that are
closely related with the present work are the studies by Brown (2008)
and Axiotou (2008)in terms of the themes such as colonial violence and
transatlantic slavery. However, these studies adopted other approaches
to explore the themes of the novels. For example, Brown used the
vocabulary of psychoanalysis to fruitfully read post-independence
literature as testimony representing the trauma of colonial occupation
while the present study combined historical, sociological and
philosophical approaches in analyzing the novels. In contrast, Axiotou
employed cross-disciplinary links between post-colonial studies and a
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
47
number of fields such as history, geography, feminism, psychoanalysis,
philosophy and political theory. Besides, the choice of the novels was
another difference. Axiotou explored Syl Cheney Coker’s The Last
Harmattan of Alusine Dunbar (1990), Ama Ata Aidoo’s The Dilemma of
a Ghost(1964), Ayi Kwei Armah’s Fragments(1970), and Buchi
Emecheta’s The Slave Girl(1979) while Brown examined Ayi Kwei
Armah’s Fragments (Ghana, the United States, and France), Tsitsi
Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions (Zimbabwe), Nuruddin Farah’s
Maps (Somalia), Moses Isegawa’s Abyssinian Chronicles (Uganda and
the Netherlands), Meja Mwangi’s Carcase for Hounds (Kenya), Helen
Oyeyemi’s The Icarus Girl (Nigeria and Britain), and in Zoở Wicomb’s
David’s Story and J. M. Coetzee’s Disgrace (South Africa).
Some studies are similar to the current study in some aspects in
terms of thematic analysis like studies conducted by Shen (2000) or Ho
(1997); however, they used different theories such as Marxism by Shen
and Fredric Jameson's concepts of "third world literature" and “national
allegory" by Ho.
Jappe’s study provided significant contribution in further
substantiating this study. This study is helpful for the current study in the
way it affirms Achebe’s role as a writer to help Africans search African
identity. This oriented the present researcher to explore Achebe, Armah
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
48
and Dangarembga’s philosophy of life gleaned from the analysis of their
novels.
In the light of differences among the studies reviewed, it can be
manifested that this study does not in any way duplicate earlier
researches. Although these studies were able to trace the themes of
historical, sociological, and philosophical perspectives, not one among
the studies focused on all of these perspective in one study to draw out
the writer’s philosophy of life.
Theoretical Framework
This study is anchored on the theories of post-colonialism and
cultural relativism as well as on Frankl’s Theory on the Meaning of Life.
Firstly, post-colonialism is a literary theory that appeared in the late
19th century at the very first moment of colonial contact and developed
throughout the 20th century. Based on Childs and Williams’ definition
(An Introduction to Post-colonial Theory, 1997,p.3)), in this study, the
word “post-colonialism” refers to the effects of the imperial power from
the moment of colonialization. Ashcroft, et. al. (1989) also maintain that
though “post-colonial” means “after colonization”, in literature, it implies
“all the experience affected by the colonial process from the beginning of
the colonization to the present day” (Ashcroft, B et al.The Empire Writes
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
49
Back: Theory and Practice in Post- Colonial Literatures, 1989, p.2).As a
theoretical approach, post colonialism asks critics to consider the way
colonialist and anti-colonialist messages are presented in literary
texts.The focus of the post-colonial critic is to expose the mechanism
and the evil effect of colonialism on the colonized. Therefore, the
concept of colonialism has political, economic and cultural implications.
The story of colonization has been narrated in literary works. That
is one reason why literature has a central place in postcolonial studies.
Post-colonial literature is the literature of authors from those countries
that experience colonization and express ideas to oppose this system.
Postcolonial literature aims at revealing the desire for independence.
Maleki & Navidi (2011) show that post-colonial literature “is not a
literature to show the colonized as the victims, but it shows their
confused sense of belonging. They find themselves in cultural, racial
and historical hybridity, which make them confused between present
and past” (Maleki & Navidi, Foregrounding Achebe’s Things Fall Apart:
A Postcolonial Study, 2011, p.11).
Post-colonialism is a dominant feature in African and Caribbean
literature because writers consider colonialism as the main reason for a
variety of traumatic consequences in their own countries. An interesting
feature of post-colonial criticism is its attempt, not only to expose the
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
50
destruction of colonialism but to reveal and discuss what the
independent nations make of themselves even after the decline of
colonialism.Typical literary works areAchebe’s Things Fall Apart
(1958),No Longer at Ease (1960), Kincaid’s A Small Place (1988), and
Obafemi’s Suicide Syndrome (1986).
Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga in their novels repeatedly
focused on impact of colonialism and crucial problems as a result of the
collision between African continent and European colonialism. The post-
colonial approach to these writers’ novels might begin by considering the
following question: how their novels, explicitly or implicitly, represent
various aspects of colonial oppression. Tentative answers to this
question can be discovered by examining No Longer at Ease,
Fragments and Nervous Conditions.
The second theory that the present study is anchored on is cultural
relativism. This theory was a response to the 19th century Western
ethnocentrism, which affirms the superiority of the European culture and
civilization over that of the native cultures of the colonies in Asia, Africa
and Latin America. The concept of cultural relativismwas developed by
Franz Boas in the first decades of the 20th century and later popularized
by his students. In 1917, Locke used the term “cultural relativism” for the
first time in his book Culture and Ethnology. Cultural relativism has
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
51
greatly influenced social sciences such as anthropology. In sociological
studies, critics sometimes employ this principle in order to avoid cultural
bias in research and to avoid evaluating another culture by their own
standards of culture.
Cultural relativism mentions a general tolerance, respect and
understanding towards people’s values, beliefs and practices. Said
(1978) in his main work, Orientalism, have used cultural relativism as a
tool to highlight the social and cultural effects of colonialism. Therefore,
cultural relativism is used as a tool to challenge Western values and to
promote an appreciation of cultural diversity.
Rachel (1999) distinguishes six different claims of cultural relativism
as follows: 1) Different societies have different moral codes; 2) There is
no objective standard that can be used to judge one societal code better
than another; 3) The moral code of a society has no special status; it is
merely one among many; 4) There are no moral truths for all peoples at
all times; 5) The moral code of a society determines what is right within
that society; and 6) It is advisable for people not to try to judge the
conduct of other peoples (Rachel, The Challenges of Cultural
RelativismInThe Elements of Moral Philosophy, 1999, p.20-36).
Despite some critical arguments towards Rachel’s theory such as
no objective truths about morality, no justification for criticizing practicùes
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
52
like slavery, female excision, infanticide, etc., critics will have more
open-minded attitude towards other cultures when examining cultural
issues.
In the present study, cultural relativism was seen as a
methodological position that explains the practices and ideas of the
African people within their cosmologies in pre-colonial and post-colonial
periods. Besides, the researcher should make sure that she did not
privilege her own understanding of the world when analyzing historical,
sociological and philosophical dimensions of the Igbo life in Achebe’s
novels. Therefore, she would have an objective and realistic view of
beauty and imperfections of African way of life.
Last but not least, the present study was also anchored on Frankl’s
theory on the meaning of life. Frankl was one of the most influential
scholars with the theory on the meaning of life. He insists that to
discover the meaning of existence, not to search for enjoyment, is an
individual’s primary concern (Ponsaran, 2007). Frankl’s concept is
based on the basis that finding a meaningful life is one’s first most
motivational force. His theory consists of the following principles: 1) Life
has meaning under all circumstances, even when a man faces the most
miserable ones; 2) The main motivation for living is the will to find
meaning in life; and 3) A man has freedom to find meaning in what he
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
53
does, and what he experiences, or at least in the stand he takes when
he had to suffer an unchangeable circumstance.
According to Frankl, a man can discover the meaning in life in three
different ways: 1) by creating a work or doing a deed; 2) by experiencing
something or encountering someone; and 3) by the attitude he takes
toward unavoidable suffering.
Besides, Frankl makes the most radical claim: in miserable
circumstance human beings can fulfil life’s deepest meaning. He opines
that there must be meaning to suffering because suffering is such an
unavoidable feature of people’s daily existence. Under these extreme
circumstances, if people can survive such experience, they are able to
find meaning in their lives.
His ideas are relevant for the present study because his theory
proposes fundamental issues about the human condition: the way of
surviving catastrophe, maintaining humanness, or finding meaning
despite catastrophe. These issues are similar to Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga’s issues on African dilemma when facing the challenges
of European colonialism. The African people faced European
imperialist aggression, military invasion and even assimilation. African
people attempted to resistEuropean colonialization and domination in
various ways. Using the power of the pen to confront the European
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
54
oppression became a major milestone in the history of African people.
These writers, like any other writer, attempted to highlight the
experiences of Africans in order to restore the true image of Africa and
regain African dignity.
Conceptual Framework
The study works on the notion that the novel presents life in a
historical perspective. Walsh (1972) claims that a novel is historical
when events and social conditions must be accurately portrayed
compared with the reality. Reyes (1985) believes that a historical novel
is a detailed reconstruction of life in a specific time and in a specific
place. In Achebe’s novels, a number of incidents are based on facts.
They present life in a specific time, which is the Igbo society in pre-
colonial and post-colonial periods. Achebe depicts historical incidents in
fictive reality. Each of his novels presents different aspects of the Igbo
society under the control of British colonialists.
Beside historical dimensions, the study also reflects social
perspectives of the society and the philosophical perspectives that may
be gleaned in the three novels of Achebe. It includes four different
aspects: social practices, religious practices, educational practices, and
political practices.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
55
Figure 1: Paradigm of the Conceptual Framework
Figure 1 shows the conceptual framework that serve as the guide in
the development of the study.
In more concrete terms, it shows the intertwine of the historical,
sociological and philosophical elements of Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga’s novels that interprets their philosophy of life.
* Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga’s
Novels:
- No Longer at Ease
-Fragments
-Nervous Conditions
*Literary Techniques
Used by Achebe,
Armah and
Dangarembga
*Literary Approaches
Used by Achebe,
Armah and
Dangarembga
Philosophy of Life of
Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga Gleaned
from the Novels
Critical Approaches for
Literary Analysis
Historical Approach
Sociological Approach
- Religious practices
- Social practices
- Educational Practices
- Political Practices
Philosophical Practices
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
56
The first box shows three of Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga’s
novels in English that serve as the primary sources and the bases for
analysis in this study: No Longer at Ease, Fragments and Nervous
Conditions. These novels are analyzed considering historical,
sociological and philosophical dimensions of the Igbo society as well as
the literary devices and approaches employed to highlight African
lifestyle in these novels.
The second box shows three contemporary approaches to literary
criticism, namely the historical, sociological and philosophical
approaches, which were employed in the study to unveil the author’s
philosophy of life.
Therefore, the philosophy of life of Achebe, Armah and
Dangarembga would be revealed through the analysis of the three
novels. The philosophy will serve as a helpful moral guide for the African
writers and readers as well.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
57
Definition of Terms
The following terms are defined conceptually and operationally for a
better understanding and appreciation of concepts as they are used in
this study:
Content Analysis. The term pertains to the process of delving into
certain situations in order to unearth their deeper meanings as
presented by the artist using his own technique and stylish pattern
(Hosillos, 1984). As used in the study, the term refers to the techniques
in analyzing message content and message handling.
Educational Practices. Operationally, the term may be defined as
habitual or customary actions relating to different aspects of education in
the Igbo society.
Historical Dimension. In this study, the term relates to the
historical conditions and events happening at the time when Chinua
Achebe’s fictions are written.
Literary Approach. As used within the context of this study, the
term may be defined as the tenets or principles that are employed to
analyze and understand literary texts. Each literary approach is a
particular way of looking at literary texts. In this study, this term refers to
historical, sociological and philosophical approaches.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
58
Literary Techniques. Literary techniques refers to the typical
structures used by writers in their works to convey his or her message in
a simple manner to his or her readers. When employed properly, the
different literary devices help readers to appreciate, interpret and
analyze a literary work. ( In this study, literary
devices refer to Achebe’s use of language and oral tradition in writing his
three novels.
Moralist. A moralist may be defined as a person who tries to teach
other people to behave in the way that he or she considers to be most
correct and honest. Within the context of this study, this term refers to
Achebe’s philosophy of life as a moralist.
Philosophical Dimension. Operationally, the term pertains to
philosophical aspects like fatalism, notion of balance and co-existence
reflected in the selections. It may be defined as habitual or customary
actions illustrating different aspects of a philosophy in the Igbo culture.
Philosophy of Life. A philosophy of life is an overall vision of or
attitude toward life and the purpose of life. Within the context of this
study, the philosophy of life refers to Achebe’s philosophy of life as a
moralist and an idealist.
Political Practices. Operationally, political practices may be
defined as habitual or customary actions illustrating the different aspects
of politics in the Igbo culture.
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
59
Post-colonialism. As used within the context of this study, this
concept deals with the effects of European power on the Igbo society
from the beginning of the colonialization.
Religious Practice. The term denotes a form of belief in Supreme
Beings by celebrating ritual rites and sometimes is only shown by
presenting something as a proof of submission to the God, a form of
offerings, and rituals.
Selected Works. Within the context of this study, the term refers to
the identified novels of Chinua Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga
entitled No Longer at Ease, Fragments and Nervous Conditions.
Social Practices. According to the UNESCO, the term pertains to
the habitual activities that structure the lives of communities and groups
and that are shared by and relevant to many of their members. In this
study, this term refers to everyday activities in the African society as
reflected in the novels of Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga.
Sociological Dimension. Operationally, the term may be defined
as the different aspects of a society reflected in a fiction, including
philosophical, social, religious, educational, and political practices.
Themes. In this study, the term relates to historical, sociological,
and philosophical perspectives present in the representative literary
works of Achebe
THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
60
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the research methodology in terms of the
research design and treatment of the materials studied.
Research Design
This study employed the qualitative method of research in
analyzing Achebe, Armah and Dangarembga’s philosophy of life in the
representative literary works chosen. According to Suter (2012), in terms
of its complex designs and methods of data analysis, qualitative
research is guided by the philosophical assumptio...er and
sister, Efua and Araba, organized not for the
sake of their belief in the ancient traditions of
their ancestors but solely for raising money.
Efua and her daughter Araba decide to have
it earlier on the 5th day following pay day.
- all things have souls and, therefore,
are alive. In this context, the dead are not
really dead but live all around us and do in
fact return either through rebirth or when
summoned through libations(pp. 5-6).
- In Fragments, the blind grandmother,
Naana, views time and life in the terms of a
traditional cyclic order: "Death, . . . now I see
in it another birth, just as among you [the
ancestral spirits] the birth of an infant here is
mourned as the traveling of another spirit" (p.
286).
Educational practices:
- education was neglected during the
Nkrumah era - a view Armah conveys in
Fragments when he refers to "an unfinished
NEW TECHNICAL SCHOOL whose
foundations were laid many years ago".
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
204
--Baako tells the production committee
that he is interested in investigating this naive
assumption of the idea of education: "So . . .
this Aggrey kind of attitude is important. The
educated really thinking of the people here as
some kind of devils in a burning hell, and
themselves the happy plucked ones, saved"
(p. 147).
Political practices:
-The view on press freedom in Ghana
during the Nkrumah era is conveyed by
Asante-Smith to Baako in Fragments when
the Director of Ghanavision tells Baako that
there are no films left for his screenplays
because they are all reserved for Nkrumah
and his ministers. Asante-Smith explains the
setup to Baako: “You'll see. We have to
follow the Head of State and try to get pretty
pictures of him and those around him ... We
had a lecture before you came. A nation is
built through glorifying its big shots. That's
our job, anyway” (p.133).
-Ocran, Baako's art teacher, explained
to Baako, when he complained:
"Nothing works in this
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
205
country ... The place is run by this
so-called elite of pompous asses
trained to do nothing. Nothing
works ... It isn't even that things
are slow. Nothing works. ..."
-The red-tapism is inherent in the Civil
Service. The principal secretary tells him:
If you come back thinking you
can make things work in any smooth,
efficient way, you’ll just get a
complete waste of time. It is not
worth bothering about (p.119).
-To Ocran's criticism of the
system which obviously does no
work, the Principal Secretary defends
the rotten setup by arguing that:
"We don't have modem
systems here. This country doesn't
work that way. If you come back
thinking you can make things work
in any smooth, efficient way, you'll
just get a complete waste of your
time. It's not work bothering about"
(pp. 82-83).
- reacting rather furiously to
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
206
having to fawn before the Principal
Secretary in order to get Baako a
job at Ghanavision because the
rotten civil service establishment
does no work, Ocran declares that:
I hate these stupid
Ghanaian big shots. They know
things don't work, but they are
happy to sit on top the mess all
the same. Now he feels he's
done us a great favor and that's
the way he wants it. You' re
expected to be grateful. The
machinery doesn't work, except
as a special favor for special
cases (p.84)
--Brempong describes Asante-Smith to
Baako with great admiration mixed with
contempt as a man with a flair for flattery and
bootlicking:
Of course ... a person like
Asante-Smith, knows people.
Besides, he is clever. One of his
own drinking friends says he has the
sweetest tongue in all Ghana for
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
207
singing his master's praises. It's the
truth, And it doesn't matter to him
even when the masters change. He
can [still] sing sweetly for anybody
who de for top (p.46).
-The angry Ocran asserts that "The
place [Civil Service or rather Ghana] is run by
this so-called elite of pompous asses trained
to do nothing. Nothing works ... There are
dozens of organizations, supposed to take
care of this and that ... [In spite of this] you
keep getting pushed into using personal
contacts" (pp. 81-82).
- Janet Scalder of the British Council, for
example, has an overwhelming degree of
authority over scripts.
-In Fragments Akosua Russel's shallow
poems also celebrate slave mentality which
resurfaces throughout in Armah's corpus.
The poem entitled "The Corning of the
Brilliant Light of the New Age to Amosema
Junction Village" recounts the glory of a
European who, aided by his Westernized
African wife, brought the magic of European
civilization and enlightenment to a primitive
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
208
African village.
- The impotence and the absurdity of
Africa's intellectuals are evoked by the fact
that the doyen of Ghana Arts, Akosua
Russell, has neither inborn intellect nor the
acquired knowledge to enable her to play the
role of patroness of Ghana's Arts and
Culture.
- Akosua Russel’s sacrifice of the
development of a robust indigenous art on
the altar of instant wealth for herself is the
death of encouragement and development of
youthful talents.
- Like Akosua Russel, the supposed
producers at Ghanavision have become
sycophants of the government in power.
Rather than produce, they share among
themselves television sets meant for the
countryside.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
209
the Middle
Passage(p.147)
the history
of the trans-
Atlantic slave
trade
- A mother/daughter dynamic offers
much potential for a reciprocal
relationship—something integral to the
growth of unhu. In contrast to Jeremiah,
Tambu recognizes her mother’s plight and
pities her for it: “The thought of my mother
working so hard, so alone, always
distressed me” (p.10). To alleviate her
mother’s burden, Tambu helps with the
chores and plans ahead, preparing dinner
to spare her mother from additional work.
Nervous
Conditions by
Dagarembga
history of
Western
exploitation and
land
dispossession
(p.18)
Social practices:
-Babamukuru’s mimicry is all-
encompassing: he appropriates English table
customs, home dộcor, and fastidious
attention to proper Western dress, evidenced
in the household’s emphasis on bleaching his
white shirts. Like his displays of wealth and
piety, the shirts are white masks with which
Babamukuru repeatedly attempts to cover his
black skin. Besides, Babamukuru’s
employment of a black African servant, Anna,
who must kneel in the family’s presence and
serve its English meals, simultaneously
affirms and mimics British colonial
- Tambu’s modeling of this unhu-
inspired relationship with her mother in
Nervous Conditions influences Netsai,
who takes pains to help her sister
whenever she can. For example, she
obtains water from the river so that Tambu
need not make the trips herself. Tambu
praises Netsai’s initiative and the two
exchange smiles.
- the close friendship between
Tambu and Nyasha promotes the
importance of female community.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
210
domination of the African.
-Nyasha is a character who struggles to
find her identity as a young Rhodesian
female:
We shouldn’t have gone’, Nyasha was
saying, looking disheartened. ’The parents
ought to have packed us off home. They
should have, you know. Lots of people did
that. Maybe that would have been the best.
For them at least, because now they‘re
stuck with hybrids for children. (79)
- Born in Africa and raised in England,
Nyasha is a child caught between two worlds
who struggles to find her place when the
family returns to Rhodesia. Having spent
most of her childhood in England, Nyasha
finds it hard to adjust to the mission
community and its expectations. She has
forgotten most of her Shona language and
traditional customs which make her feel like
an outsider at family gatherings.
- Nyasha has adopted the English way
of life and appears as a modern English
young girl both in appearance and behaviour.
- The group cooking experience
enables Tambu to “occupy the corner that
that same natural process had carved out
for me. It was comfortable to recognize
myself as solid, utilitarian me” (40).
- Out of this imperfect situation of
unending chores, Tambu, Nyasha, and
Maiguru’s three helpers carve out some
enjoyment. The homestead’s rural
location offers many opportunities to
commune with nature, and Tambu and the
other young women find solace in their
time outdoors, which offers a “desilencing
of women through landscape and a
finding of womanist spaces of refuge in it.
- The girls derive happiness from
walking to the River Nyamarira even
though the purpose of obtaining water is
to continue washing and cooking
-Mai laments the loss of Nhamo
during the Christmas holiday, and Lucia
assures Mai, “We do not deny you your
grief, but let the anger be over” (143).
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
211
She speaks English fluently, smokes
cigarettes and wear short modern dresses
“hardly enough of it to cover her thighs” (37).
She is severely controlled by her father who
demands good school results in order to
secure her future as a good missionary wife.
- According to Babamukuru it is
“important to be good, to listen to what we,
your parents tell you to do, to study your
books diligently and not let your mind be
distracted by other things.” (89).
-In fear of the anticipated consequences
Tambu’s mother strongly objects to sending
Tambu to the mission:
You Jeremiah, are you mad? Have
you eaten some wild scrub that has gone to
your head? I think so, otherwise how could
you stand there and tell me to send my
child to a place of death, the place where
my first child died! Today you are raving!
She will not go. Unless you want me to die
too. The anxiety will kill me. I will not let her
go. (56)
-Early in the story, the main protagonist,
Tambu, states, “[t]he needs and sensibilities
Later, when Mai becomes so devastated
regarding Tambu’s acceptance to the
Young Ladies’ College of the Sacred
Heart that she ceases to eat or feed her
baby, Dambudzo, Lucia again takes a firm
yet sympathetic approach when
comforting her sister. Tambu’s reference
to Lucia’s forcing of Mai to take
responsibility for her son as a kind of
“shock treatment” (188) at first appears
negative. Yet, Lucia’s plan to situate
Dambudzo on a rock and threaten Mai to
let him drown is intended as loving,
effective shock therapy and is followed
with rejuvenating sun-bathing on a rock
and conversations with affable local
women who exchange playful banter.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
212
of the women in [her] family were not
considered a priority” (Dangarembga p.12).
- The traditional patriarchal structure of
the Shona family is also obvious when it
comes to food. First, women are required to
prepare the food. Second, the best food is
reserved for the males, leaving the youngest
female members of the family with whatever
is left. In addition, if larger groups eat at the
homestead, the women and children usually
eat in the kitchen, a symbol of women’s
restricted space. Tambu reflects, “there was
not enough [meat] left in the pot to make a
meal for those [] who were not dining [in
the house]. As a result the youngest of [them]
had only gravy and vegetables to go with
[their] sadza” (Dangarembga 41).
- The patriarchal structure of the family
is also shown, for instance, in privileging
boys over girls. Throughout the novel the
reader is made aware that male offspring in
the family are more important than female
offspring (Dangarembga 129, 138, 183).
- The unequal treatment is seen in the
privileging of boys’ education while trivializing
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
213
girls’ education.
- The superiority of men and
insignificance of women is mirrored by the
narrator when she recounts the great efforts
that were made to welcome their uncle’s
family.
- The female characters are labeled
negatively if they do not act in the expected
feminine way. Often, their male family
members refer to them as 'man' or
'unnatural'.
-Dangarembga vividly depicts typical
patriarchs in her novel. They are Tambu’s
uncle, Babamukuru, is depicted as the
ultimate patriarch, while his younger brother
Jeremiah, Tambu’s father, displays a
patriarchal attitude but lacks rationality and
dignity.
- Dangarembga does not only provide
examples of adult patriarchal characters like
Babamukuru and Jeremiah, she also
describes two young patriarchal characters
like Nhamo, Tambu’s brother.
- Chido, Nyasha’s brother, is another
young patriarch character who deploys a
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
214
silent and uncritical acceptance of the
patriarchal status quo. As a boy, Chido is
granted more freedom than his sister. To a
much lesser degree than his cousin Nhamo,
Chido supports patriarchal notions.
- Tambu’s mother, Mainini, is a typical
example of a woman that has accepted her
role and tasks in patriarchal society. She
describes “womanhood [] as a heavy
burden”.(p.16).
- Dangarembga states a fact that the
male is allowed to voice his story whereas
the female has no right to voice her story.
- This tradition describes the fact that a
wife remained a stranger, an outsider to her
husband’s kin [] [and was] expected to
obey first their fathers, then their husbands.
- Another tradition is that most women
grew additional vegetables in their own little
gardens with the harvest at their disposal.
This tradition gave women a source of
income which was otherwise unavailable to
them.
- Christian missionaries also spread the
Western type of patriarchy. Women were
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
215
taught to obey and serve their husbands. The
duties and responsibilities as Victorian wives
introduced new restrictions for women.
Religious practices:
-Dangarembga depicts how Tambu
adopts the views of social hierarchy by
Christian missionaries:
[The missionaries] were about
God’s business here in darkest
Africa. They had given up the
comforts and security of their own
homes to come and lighten our
darkness. It was a big sacrifice [.]
[] [Their] self-denial and brotherly
love did not go unrewarded. We
treated them like minor deities. []
Today [] [t]hey are called
expatriates [] [b]ut they are
deified in the same way as the
missionaries were because they
are white so that their coming is
still an honour. [] I used to feel
guilty and unnatural for not being
able to love the Whites as I ought.
[I]t did not take long for me to learn
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
216
that they were in fact more
beautiful and then I was able to
love them. (Dangarembga 105-
106)
- Babamukuru is a member of the
Christian missionary church and has adopted
the Christian and Western norms. For
example, to prevent traditional Shona
polygamy in his family, Babamukuru forces
his brother to have a Christian wedding.
-When Tambu is offered a scholarship at
the nuns convent, Nyasha points out how the
colonizers will brainwash her. She remarks
that “it would be a marvelous opportunity []
[t]o forget who you were, what you were and
why you were that” (Dangarembga 182).
Educational practices:
- A glimpse of the sort of uncritical
education colonial school children are
exposed to is given by Tambu in the following
passage:
[O]ur teacher said he had taught
us the entire syllabus so it was up to
us to embed what he had taught us
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
217
firmly in our memories. So, instead of
classes, we had revision periods. Mr.
Sanyati divided us up into groups and
sent us outside with the life-cycle of
the Anopheles mosquito, the dates of
the Boer rebellion, the ordinary,
comparative and superlative of
irregular adjectives, and expected us
to be able to recite them by rote
when we came back into the
classroom.(176, my emphasis)
- When Tambu arrives her new home,
she can read “everything from Enid Blyton to
the Bronte sisters.” (94) The missionary
education’s curriculum was held in consistent
accordance with the British syllabus and
emphasized religious instruction together
with English as the main language.
- Nhamo willingly imbibes everything
western and he claims that he can no longer
speak his mother tongue. He has thus lost
the values of his own people, who disregard
him because he can no longer communicate
with them, but also his “native” identity.
- During Tambu’s first visit at the
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
218
homestead after her stay at the mission, she
is disgusted and embarrassed by the dirt and
feels estranged from her mother. Realizing
the change that Tambu undergoes, Mainini
claims that Tambu has become ashamed of
her.
-Nyasha is deeply aware of this process.
She voices discontent with the prospect of
colonial education when she points to the fact
that “there [are] more evils than advantages
to be reaped” from going to a Western-style
school:
It would be a marvelous
opportunity, she said sarcastically, to
forget. To forget who you were, what
you were and why you were that. The
process, she said, was called
assimilation, and that was what was
intended for the precocious few who
might prove a nuisance if left to
themselves, whereas the others -well
really, who cared about the others?
So they made a little space into
which you were assimilated, an
honorary space in which you could
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
219
join them and they could make sure
that you behaved yourself. (178)
- The differences in the quality of
European and African schools are pointed
out in Nervous Conditions. “[E]verybody
knew that the European schools had better
equipment, better teachers, better furniture,
better food, better everything” (Dangarembga
182).
- Tambu’s struggle for education also
mirrors an entire people’s struggle for
education. The youth generation strives even
more for education and good grades. Tambu
perceives education as an opportunity to fly
from poverty and patriarchy.
Political practices:
- During a mental breakdown, in a very
fragmented way, Nyasha condemns the
entire colonial system and its manipulation:
“[My parents] have done it to me.
[] It’s not their fault. They did it to
them too. You know they did[.] [] To
both of them, but especially to him.
They put him through it all. But it’s not
his fault, he’s good . [] “Why do
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
220
they do it, Tambu, she hissed
bitterly, her face contorting with rage to
me and to you and to him? []
They’ve taken us away. [] All of us.
They’ve deprived you of you, him of
him, ourselves of each other. They’ve
trapped us. But I won’t be trapped, I’m
not a good girl. I won’t be trapped.
(Dangarembga 204-205)
- The European ộlite undertook to
manufacture a native ộlite. They picked out
promising adolescents; they branded them,
as with a red-hot iron, with the principles of
Western culture; they stuffed their mouths full
with high-sounding phrases, grand glutinous
words that stuck to the teeth. After a short
stay in the mother country they were sent
home, white-washed. Babamukuru
represents a member of this native ộlite.
Unilateral
Declaration of
Independence
(UDI) in 1965
(p.93)
the
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
BATANGASSTATEUNIVERSITY
Republic of the Philippines
221
beginning of the
liberation war,
the guerilla
fighters
Philosophy of Life of African Writers Gleaned from the Analysis of their Novels
Achebe A moralist
A teacher
Armah A moralist
A teacher
A philosopher
Dagarembga A role model of African women
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
222
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Primary Sources
Achebe, C.(1960). No Longer at Ease. London. Heinemann
Achebe, C.(2000). Home and Exile. Oxford University Press.
Achebe, C.(1964).The Role of the Writer in a New Nation. Nigeria
Magazine.
Achebe, C.(1970). Commitment and African Writers. Africa Report.
Achebe, C.(1988). The Novelist as Teacher. In Hopes and
Impediments: Selected Essays. New York: Doubleday.
Achebe, C. (2009). The Education of a British-Protected Child. New
York: Random House
Armah, A.K.(1971). Fragments. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Dangarembga, T. (1988). Nervous Conditions. 1988. Oxfordshire,
UK: Ayebia Clarke.
Secondary Sources
Abrams, M.H.(1981). A Glossary of Literary Terms. New York.
London: Holt Rinchar & Wilson.
Amuta, C.(1992). Portrait of the Contemporary Artist in Armah’s
Novels.Critical Perspectives on Ayi Kwei Armah. Ed. Derek Wright.
Three Continents Press. 13 - 21
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
223
Azodo, A.U. (2010). A Zimbabwean Ethic of Humanity: Tsitsi
Dangarembga’s The Book of Not and the Unhu Philosophy of
Personhood.New Novels in African Literature Today 27 (2010): 117-
29. Print.
Ashcroft, B et al. (1989). The Empire Writes Back: Theory and
Practice in Post- Colonial Literatures. London: Routledge.
Chennels, A. (1996). Authorizing Women, Women’s Authoring: Tsitsi
Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions. New Writing from Southern
Africa. Ed. Emmanuel Ngara. Studies in African Literature.
Portsmouth: Heinemann, 59-75.
Childs, P & Williams, R.J.P. (1997). An Introduction to Post-colonial
Theory. London : Prentice Hall.
Diamond, L. (1989). Fiction as Political Thought. African Affairs, 88
(352), 435-445.
Eckert, L. S (2006). How does It Mean? : Engaging Reluctant
Readers through Literary Theory. Heinemann
Ezeigbo, A.T. (1989). Ayi Kwei Armah: Neocolonialism and the
African Woman. Ernest Emenyonu (Ed) Literature and National
Consciousness. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books Ltd.
Gelfand, M. (1973). The Genuine Shona. Gwelu, Zimbabwe: Mambo
P. Print.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
224
Gikandi, S. (Ed) (2009). The Routledge Encyclopedia of African
LiteratureLondon: Routledge Taylor and Francis Group.
Haizel, E. A. (1993). Education in Ghana. In The Life and Work of
Kwame Nkrumah. Ed. Kwame Arhin. Trenton: Africa World Press,
Inc.,
Hosillos, L. (1984). Originally as Vengeance in Philipine Literature.
Quezon City, Philipines: New Day Publishers.
Innes, C.L. (1990). Chinua Achebe. Cambridge: CUP.
Irele, A. (1971). The Criticism of Modern African Literature. In
Heywood, C.(1971). Perspectives on African Literature, London:
Heinemann.
Madubuike, I. (1974). Analaysis Achebe’s Ideas on Literature. Black
World.
Mugo, M.G. (2004). African Orature and Human Rights in Gikuyu,
Shona, and Ndebele Zamani Cultures. Harare, Zimbabwe: Sapes
Books.
Ngugi Wa Thiong’O (1981). Writers in Politics. London: Heinemann
Publishers Ltd.
Nwala, T.U. (1985). Igbo Philosophy. Lantern Books, Ikeja, Lagos.
Ogede, O. (2000). Ayi kwei Armah Radical Iconoclast Pitting
Imaginary Worlds Against the Actual. Ohio Uuniversity Press.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
225
Okpewho, I (1992). African Oral Literature: Backgrounds, Character,
and Continuity. Bloomington: Indiana University Press
Otite, O & Ogionwo.W. (1979). An Introduction To Sociological
Studies. Ibadan: Heinemann.
Rachels J. (1999). The Elements of Moral Philosophy. (3rd ed.)
Singapore: McGraw-Hill.
Rand, A. (1975). Romantic Manifesto: A Philosophy of
Literature. New York: Penguin Books Ltd..
Reyes, S.S. (1985). Philippine Literature since 1972: A Discourse in
Disorder In The Romance Mode in Philippine Popular Literature and
Other Essays. Manila: De La Salle University Press.
Said, Edward W. (1978) Orientalism. New York: Vintage Books.’
Said, Edward W. (1993) Culture and Imperialism. New York: Vintage
Books.
Schmidt, M.R. (2002). Constructing a Life Philosophy: Opposing
Viewpoint. Greenhaven Press, Inc.
Suter, W. N. (2012). Introduction to Educational Research: A Critical
Thinking Approach. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.
Teoxon, L.J.F. (1990). The Quest for Truth. Quezon City, Philipines:
New Day Publishers.
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
226
Tomeldan, Y. V., et al. (1986). An Introduction to Literature. Manila,
Philippines: National Bookstore Publishers
Veit-Wild, Flora. (1992). Teachers, Preachers, Non-Believers: A
Social History of Zimbabwean Literature. London: Hans Zell
Walsh, J. P. (1972).History Is Fiction. The Horn Book.
Webb, A.C (2001). Literature & Lives: A Response-Based, Cultural
Studies Approach to Teaching English. National Council of Teachers
of English
Unpublished Theses and Dissertations
Ayivor, M.G.K. (1998). A Saga of black Deglorification: the
Disfigurement of Africa in Ayi Kwei Armah’s Novels. Unpublished
Doctoral Dissertation. University of Cape Town.
Axiotou, G. (2008). Breaking the Silence: West African Authors and
the Transatlantic Slave Trade. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation.
The University of Edinburgh
Brown, M.L. (2008). Scream Somehow Echoing: Trauma and
Testimony in Anglophone African Literature. Unpublished Doctoral
Dissertation. University of Maryland.
Bubenechik, M (2012). Trauma Novels in Postcolonial Literatures:
Tsitsi Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions, and Tomson Highway, Kiss
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
227
of the Fur Queen. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation. Heinrich-Heine-
Universitọt Dỹsseldorf
Ho, Ann-lin, Wendy, (1997). A Study of Chinua Achebe’s Five Novels
in Relation to Fredric Jameson's Concepts of "National Allegory" and
"Third World Literature. Unpublished Master Thesis. University of
Hong Kong.
Jappe, T.S. (2001). The Search for Identity in Things Fall Apart, A
Man of the People, Anthills of the Savannah and Selected Essays by
Chinua Achebe.Unpublished MasterThesis. University of Hong Kong.
Nash, H. (1997). A Novel Approach to Education and Development:
Insights from African Women Writers. Unpublished MasterThesis
Massey University
Rodgers, R.J. (2013). Representations of Women, Identity and
Education in the Novels of Tsitsi Dangarembga and Kopano Matlwa.
Unpublished MasterThesis. Stellenbosch University.
Shen, B. (2000). Strangers in Their Own Land: the Issue of Social
Class & the Dilemma of Individuals in Three Novels by Chinua
Achebe. Unplublished Master Thesis. University of Regina.
Periodicals
Alkire, S. Teaching Novels in EFL/ESL Classes. The English Learning
and Language Review. Retrieved from
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
228
10/10/2014.
Ashaolu, A.O (1980). “A Vision of Society in the Novels of Ayi Kwei
Armah”. Ashaolu, A.O. and Asein, S.O (Eds) Studies in the African
Novel. Vol. 1. Ibadan: Ibadan University Press.
Dzobo, N.K."African Symbols and Proverbs as Sources of
Knowledge" in Person and Community: Ghanaian Philosophical
Studies, I. eds. Kwasi Wiredu and Kwame Gyekye, CRVP.Series II.
Africa, VOL.1, 85.
Maleki, N & Navidi, M. (2011). Foregrounding Achebe’s Things Fall
Apart: A Postcolonial Study. Canadian Social Science, Canada, v.7,
n.6, p.10-15
Ogungbesan, K. (1975). Symbolism and Meaning in the The
Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born. African Literature Today, Number
7.
Ojaide, T. (1992). Modern African Literature and Cultural Identity.
African Studies Review. Vol. No.3 pp.43-57.
Ponsaran, A. G. (2007). The philosophical foundations of Viktor
Frankl's logotherapy. Philippiniana Sacra, 42(125), 339-354.
Seidel, J. V. (1998). Qualitative Data Analysis. (Originally published
as Qualitative Data Analysis in The Ethnograph v5.0: A Users Guide,
Appendix E, 1998, Colorado Springs, CO: Qualis Research.)
THAINGUYENUNIVERSITY
SocialistRepublic of Vietnam
229
Staudt, K. The Characterization of Women in Soyinka and Armah. Ba
Shiry (University of Wincosin, Madison), 8, 2, pp.63-69.
Websites
Braiman,J.(2007).Literary Devices. Retrieved from
https://kohner.wikispaces.com/file/view/LITERARY+DEVICES.pdf
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- historical_sociological_and_philosophical_dimensions_reflect.pdf